Downtown
Toronto Turbine has “No Significant Impact” on Avian Mortality
TORONTO,
ON, 2004-02-05 (canadian
association for renewable energies) The first downtown wind turbine
in North America has killed two birds in its first year of operation.
Forty million
birds fly over Toronto during migration periods, but a study by Toronto
Hydro and WindShare shows that mortality from the turbine at Exhibition
Place “has had no significant impact on local and migrating
bird populations.”
The Exhibition
Place Wind Turbine Bird Monitoring Study was conducted during last
spring and fall, and concluded that the level of mortality “is
absolutely insignificant when compare! d with the thousands of birds
killed annually, in Toronto, by striking tall buildings.”
It says
the mortality rate is closer to that of an individual house where
birds hit windows at a rate of between one and ten per year, and said
every feral (free roaming) cat in Toronto is capable of killing more
than 1,000 small animals including birds per year.
Local birds
“appear to have adapted easily to the presence of the turbine
and simply avoid it,” the report notes. “
Bird flocks
were seen arriving daily to forage on lawns and landed in parking
lots soon after dawn, and always took a flight path that clearly avoided
coming close to the turbine.”
Toronto
Hydro and WindShare installed the $1.3 million Lagerwey 750 kW turbine
to supply green power to the city.
"Toronto
is gifted with a large and diverse population of birds,” says
Ed Hale of WindShare. “I am pleased that this report demonstrates
a high level of comfort and adaptability among the many species of
birds living at the win! d turbine site.”
WindShare
is Canada's first green power community co-operative that was started
by the Toronto Renewable Energy Co-operative.
"We're
very excited to confirm our predictions that the wind turbine would
have minimum impact on local and migrating birds," adds Joyce
McLean of Toronto Hydro Energy Services.
"Having
the turbine become such an unobtrusive part of the bird environment
only further confirms that we installed the turbine for all of the
right reasons."
The Lagerwey
turbine generates sound levels of 43 decibels at a distance of 250
m, compared with levels of 48-52 dB in a quiet suburban residential
neighbourhood and 58-62 dB in an urban residential environment.
—Bill
Eggertson
canadian
association for renewable energies